Bad Marxism: Capitalism and Cultural Studies by John Hutnyk

By John Hutnyk

Cultural reviews normally claims to be a thorough self-discipline. This publication thinks that is a nasty evaluate. Cultural theorists like to toy with Marx, yet severe considering turns out to fall into seen traps. After an advent and is the reason why the 'Marxism' of the academy is unrecognisable and mostly unrecognised in anti-capitalist struggles, undesirable Marxism offers unique analyses of Cultural experiences' adored strikes by means of retaining fieldwork, files, empires, hybrids and trade up opposed to the sensible feedback of anti-capitalism. enticing with the paintings of key thinkers: Jacques Derrida, James Clifford, Gayatri Spivak, Georges Bataille, Homi Bhabha, Michael Hardt and Toni Negri, Hutnyk concludes via advocating an open Marxism that's either pro-party and pro-critique, whereas being neither dogmatic, nor dull.

Show description

Read or Download Bad Marxism: Capitalism and Cultural Studies PDF

Best communism & socialism books

Post-Marxism Versus Cultural Studies: Theory, Politics and Intervention (Taking on the Political)

Post-Marxism as opposed to Cultural reviews is an leading edge exploration of the moral and political importance of Cultural reviews and Post-Marxist discourse conception. It argues that even though Cultural experiences and post-Marxism are likely to current themselves as precise entities, they really percentage a undertaking -- that of taking over the political.

The Place of Marxism in History (Revolutionary Studies Series)

At a time whilst many repentant leftists are proclaiming Marxism incapable of explaining the hot phenomena of the final sector of the 20th century, Ernest Mandel reminds us that Marxism drew from its very inception at the advances of the entire social sciences and emancipation routine of its time. In a survey of the a number of resources of Marx and Engels' conception, Mandel identifies the explicit contribution of the 2 acquaintances within the quite a few disciplines to which they utilized themselves: philosophy, political economic climate, social historical past, progressive agency, self-organisation of the operating classification, emancipation routine, and internationalism.

Lithuanian social democracy in perspective, 1893-1914

Lithuanian Social Democracy in standpoint is the 1st publication in any Western language on Lithuanian Social Democracy. during this paintings Leonas Sabaliunas reports the clash among and convergence of socialism and nationalism in pre-1914 Lithuania. He analyzes the interaction of ideological priorities by way of looking at the operations of Marxist political events, emphasizing the origins, improvement, and achievements of the Social Democratic celebration of Lithuania.

Additional info for Bad Marxism: Capitalism and Cultural Studies

Example text

I think it is symptomatic that it takes 180 pages in The Predicament of Culture before there is even a hint that Louis Aragon had taken up revolutionary politics. Leiris’ politics seem to have been elided by the literary appreciation Clifford provides. Except for a brief reference to Les Temps Modernes (Clifford 1982:197), and a few other asides, Leiris is more readily rendered as the diarist and documentarist of the everyday mundane. With a nod to towards the influence of Aimé Césaire and anticolonial struggle in Vietnam and Madagascar,6 very quickly Clifford has Leiris packed off to study with Mauss after just the one brief outrage: he is reported hanging out of a window denouncing France at a surrealist meeting before he settles down into a ‘more concrete application of his subversive literary talents’ (Clifford 1988:122).

Clifford himself is heavily influenced by the ethnographic diary style of Leiris, although we might argue that his ‘most direct literary model’ is Malinowski’s Diary, with polyglot exchanged for trinketisation. qxd 5/8/04 10:46 PM Page 38 38 Bad Marxism the South Seas, and throughout his work with plenty of references to books like Moby Dick and Between the Devil and the Deep Blue Sea. Maybe not too much more of theoretical interest can be made of Malinowski’s Diary, but there is ample evidence in Clifford’s essay ‘On Ethnographic Self-fashioning’ that Malinowski’s polyglossaria is the key (Clifford 1988:97).

No solidarity politics can be successfully built on such a basis. It can be contended that this belongs to a sustained (somewhat absent-minded) anti-Marxism on Clifford’s part – here bad Marxism manifests in its negative form. Clifford’s understanding of economic production is drawn from a sketchy version of Marxism found not in Marx but in anthropological consumption texts (especially Miller 1987, 1994, 1995), and admittedly brilliant but quite idiosyncratic forms of Marxist ethnography (Taussig 1980, 1987).

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.04 of 5 – based on 16 votes